Dear Rawn, >> I don't believe that John actually used this as a justification. In fact, I didn't understand any of what he wrote as a justification or excuse for smoking tobacco. :) To my mind, he seemed to merely be asking a question about Eucharistic magic. It is important to note that often the underlying will of the *All* is present in ways the author of a note/article/book/song etc. is often never aware of, and the underlying meaning can only be unlocked by those gifted with sufficient insight and development. The underlying intent of the post was for the author to be made aware that smoking is not healthy and to have a self created veil lifted with which he can subsequently work. Your own analogy of balancing the negative aspects of smoking with positive expectorants is very telling. A useful analogy would be a murderer who subsequently seeks absolution; to his mind the negative aspect may have been balanced out by the positive but it doesn't make the initial negative act any healthier or better in the first place. Interestingly you state you have a physcial addiction, but have sorted out the emtional level of your problem. This still doesn't change the fact you have a physical and negative addiction, which you need to balance out with healing remedies and magic. The fact that this negativity has manifest physically and remained is very important. Occasional smoking can indeed be useful as a stimulant for certain activities, but claiming that a consitent phsyical addiction (and your wonderful yellow teeth!) is not negative puts out a highly incorrect and negative message to the more impressopnable and less strongly willed. Regards, Mark